Antony Eagle

PDF version

Contact Details

Department of Philosophy, School of Humanities
University of Adelaide
Kaurna Yarta
SA 5005, Australia

Academic Positions

University of Adelaide, Associate Professor of Philosophy (2021–), Senior Lecturer in Philosophy (2013–20).
University of Oxford, University (CUF) Lecturer in Philosophy.
Exeter College, Oxford, William Kneale Fellow and Tutor in Philosophy.
Tenured (‘Reappointed to retirement age’), 2009.

Notable Grants, Fellowships, Awards, and Visiting Appointments

Australian Research Council Discovery Project, Everything in its Place: Location, Persistence, and Change, Chief Investigator (Partner Investigators: Cody Gilmore and Shieva Kleinschmidt), $224,672.
Carl Friedrich von Siemens Research Fellowship of the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation for Experienced Researchers, October 2016–March 2017, €22,780.
Visiting Fellow, Munich Center for Mathematical Philosophy, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München.
Visiting scholar, Department of Philosophy, Monash University, November–December 2010.
Arts and Humanities Research Council (UK) Research Leave Scheme: Counterfactuals, Chance and Ability, grant ID No: AH/E003184/1, £23,445.
MA (by resolution), University of Oxford.
Mrs Giles Whiting Foundation Honorific Fellowship in the Humanities.


PhD, Philosophy, Princeton University.
On Some Scientific Modalities, supervisor: Bas C van Fraassen.
MA, Philosophy of Science, Princeton University.
BA (Hons), Philosophy, University of Melbourne.

Research and Teaching Interests

Areas of Specialisation
Metaphysics, Philosophy of Probability, Philosophy of Physics, Philosophy of Language, General Philosophy of Science.
Areas of Competence
Philosophical Logic, Epistemology, Early Modern Philosophy (particularly Descartes, Cavendish, and Hume), Philosophy of Religion, Philosophy of Mathematics, Philosophy of Economics



in preparation
Probability and Inductive Logic, Cambridge Elements in Philosophy and Logic, Cambridge University Press, under contract.

Edited Book

(ed.) Philosophy of Probability: Contemporary Readings, Routledge: London. (Includes more than 50,000 words of peer-reviewed editorial matter.) [Publisher]

Journal Articles (Peer-Reviewed)

‘Weak Location’, dialectica 73 (1-2): 149–81. doi:10.1111/1746-8361.12264
‘Chance, Determinism, and Unsettledness’, Philosophical Studies 176 (3): 781–802. doi:10.1007/s11098-018-1039-1
‘Persistence, Vagueness, and Location’, Journal of Philosophy 113 (10): 507–32. doi:10.5840/jphil20161131035
‘Multiple Location Defended’, Philosophical Studies 173 (8): 2215–31. doi:10.1007/s11098-015-0605-z
‘Deterministic Chance’, Noûs 45 (2): 269–99. doi:10.1111/j.1468-0068.2010.00771.x
‘Mathematics and Conceptual Analysis’, Synthese 161 (1): 67–88. doi:10.1007/s11229-006-9151-8
‘Telling Tales’, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 107 (2): 125–47. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9264.2007.00215.x
‘Reply to Stone on Counterpart Theory and Four-Dimensionalism’, Analysis 67 (2): 159-62. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8284.2007.00667.x
‘Randomness is Unpredictability’, British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 56 (4): 749–90. doi:10.1093/bjps/axi138
‘A Note on Dolby and Gull on Radar Time and the Twin “Paradox”’, American Journal of Physics 73 (10): 976–979. doi:10.1119/1.1994855 [arXiv].
‘Twenty-One Arguments against Propensity Analyses of Probability’, Erkenntnis 60 (3): 371–416. doi:10.1023/B:ERKE.0000023408.61887.6a

Book Chapters (Peer-Reviewed)

‘Relativity and the A-theory’, pp. 86–98 in Eleanor Knox and Alastair Wilson, eds., The Routledge Companion to Philosophy of Physics, Routledge. doi:10.4324/9781315623818-11
‘Probability’, pp. 417–39 in Paul Humphreys, ed., The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy of Science, Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199368815.013.24
‘Probability and Randomness’, pp. 440–59 in Alan Hájek and Christopher Hitchcock, eds., The Oxford Handbook of Probability and Philosophy, Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199607617.013.22
‘Is the Past a Matter of Chance?’, pp. 126–58 in Alastair Wilson, ed., Chance and Temporal Asymmetry, Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199673421.003.0007
‘Chance versus Randomness’, in Edward N Zalta (ed.) Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (major revision 2012). [SEP]
‘Perdurance and Location’, pp. 53–94 in Dean W. Zimmerman, ed., Oxford Studies in Metaphysics, volume 5, Oxford University Press.
‘Duration in Relativistic Spacetime’, pp. 113–7 in Dean W. Zimmerman, ed., Oxford Studies in Metaphysics, volume 5, Oxford University Press.
‘Causal Structuralism, Dispositional Actualism, and Counterfactual Conditionals’, pp. 65–99 in Toby Handfield, ed., Dispositions & Causes, Oxford University Press.
‘Pragmatic Causation’, pp. 156–90 in Huw Price and Richard Corry, eds., Causation, Physics and the Constitution of Reality: Russell’s Republic Revisited, Oxford University Press.

Essay Reviews

‘Yuri Balashov, Persistence and Spacetime’, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, 2011.09.24. [NDPR]
‘A Causal Theory of Chance?’, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science 35 (4): 883–90. doi:10.1016/j.shpsa.2004.08.003

Minor Reviews

‘A J Cotnoir and Donald L M Baxter, eds., Composition as Identity’, Australasian Journal of Philosophy 94: 190–3. doi:10.1080/00048402.2015.1053954
‘Helen Steward, A Metaphysics for Freedom’, Australasian Journal of Philosophy 91: 833. doi:10.1080/00048402.2013.806565
‘D H Mellor, Probability: A Philosophical Introduction’, Mind 115: 773–7. doi:10.1093/mind/fzl773
‘Tim Maudlin, Truth and Paradox’, Philosophical Quarterly 56: 455–7. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9213.2006.00453.x
‘John Hawthorne, Knowledge and Lotteries’, Australasian Journal of Philosophy 83: 451–2. doi:10.1080/00048400500192022


forall\(x\) Adelaide, ‘with’ P D Magnus and Tim Button. Free, open source textbook for introductory logic. Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 license. [GitHub]
not ongoing
Elements of Deductive Logic, free, open source textbook for introductory-intermediate logic course. Creative Commons CC BY-SA 4.0 license. [GitHub]
‘Philosophy and Probability’, Exeter College Association Register: 55–58. [link]

Recent Presentations

(¶=keynote, †=contributed, others invited)

TBA, ANU Philosophy.
December 2019
‘Location Relations’†, NZAP Auckland.
‘Appearance and the A-theory’, Time and Emergence, UWA.
July 2019
‘Rational Forgetting?’†, AAP Wollongong.
‘Endurance and the A-Theory’, Time and Other Matters workshop, University of Adelaide.
June 2019
‘What is Supendurance?’†, IAPT 6, Boulder, CO, USA.
November 2018
‘Can Structuralism Avoid Putnam’s Paradox?’, Structural Realism Meets Structural Representation workshop, University of Sydney.
July 2018
‘How Everything Is’†, AAP Wellington.
June 2018
‘How Everything Is’†, IAPT 5, Seoul, South Korea.
December 2017
‘Stakes and Standpoints’†, NZAP Otago.

Prior to this, talks at: AAP† (multiple), Aberdeen, About Aboutness (Melbourne), ANU (multiple), Australian Metaphysics Conference† (multiple), Aristotelian Society, Arizona Ontology Conference, Auckland, Barcelona, Bristol, British Society for the Philosophy of Science, BSPS conference† (Sussex), Cambridge (Serious Metaphysics Group), Canterbury (NZ), Carolina Metaphysics Workshop, Causal Republicanism† (Centre for Time, Sydney), CRNAP Modality workship (Princeton), Determinism (ANU), FAU-Erlangen, Fictionalism (Manchester), From Here to Eternity: Temporal Experience and Transformation (Centre for Time, Sydney), Université de Genève, Hume’s Metaphysics and Humean Metaphysics (University of Tampere) La Trobe, Leeds, Leeds HPS, LEM forum (Institute of Philosophy, London), Levels of Causation workshop (IHPST, Paris), London Logic & Metaphysics forum, LSE (Sigma Club), McGill, Munich Centre for Mathematical Philosophy (LMU-München), Melbourne, Metaphysics of Science¶ (Nottingham), Metaphysics of Science (Melbourne), Monash (twice), Nature of Indeterminacy workshop (Leeds), Notre Dame, Nottingham (thrice), NYU, NZAP† (multiple), Otago, Oxford, Oxford (Philosophy of Physics, twice), Paris Diderot (PhilMath Seminar), PERSP Space & Time Workshop on the Open Future (Barcelona), Philosophy and Probability International Summer School† (Konstanz), Philosophy of Probability Graduate Conference III¶ (LSE), Reading, Sydney Winter School on Physics and Philosophy of Time 2017, Time, Agency and Causation (Centre for Time, Sydney), Time Symmetry (Centre for Time, Sydney), Time Travel and Probability (Centre for Time, Sydney), UIC, UMass Amherst, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Université de Neuchâtel, VUW, Williams College.


Primary supervisor except where noted.


Katherine Dormandy, Rationality: An Expansive Bayesian Theory, Oxford, DPhil, co-supervisor.
Barbara Vetter, Potentiality and Possibility, Oxford, DPhil, co-supervisor.
Luke Fenton-Glynn, A Probabilistic Analysis of Causation, Oxford, DPhil.


In progress
Anthony Bishop, Underdetermination and Theoretical Values, Adelaide, MPhil.
Riley Harris, Moral Uncertainty: Knowledge, Decision and Deliberation, Adelaide, MPhil.
Jessica Pohlmann, Reality’s Hierarchical Structure: On the Foundations of Asymmetric Dependence Relations, Adelaide, MPhil.
James Vlachoulis, A Defence of the B-Theory of Time with Respect to the Problem of Change, Adelaide, MPhil.
Atheer Al-Khalfa, Donnellan’s Referential/Attributive Distinction, Adelaide, MPhil.
Danny Wardle, Opening a Can of Spacetime Worms: The Metaphysics of Persistence, Adelaide, MPhil.
Brigitte Everett, Temporal Passage: Dynamic Experiences and the B-theory, Adelaide, MPhil.
Rebecca Randell, Beyond Dualism: The Challenge for Feminist Theory, Adelaide, MPhil, co-supervisor.
Michael Lazarou, Vindicating Vague Objects, Adelaide, MPhil.
Mark Coleman, Realist and Anti-Realist Approaches in Philosophy of Science: Perspective and Representational Pluralism in Scientific Discovery, Adelaide, MPhil, co-supervisor.
Seungil Lee, Restricted Material Composition, Oxford, BPhil.
Harjit Bhogal, Laws and Modelling in Economics, Oxford, BPhil.
Luke Fenton-Glynn, Causation and Causal Explanation, Oxford, BPhil.
John Poland, Dispositions and Laws of Nature, Oxford, BPhil.

Honours/Undergraduate Theses

Samuel Parsons, The Ontology of Social Entities: A Set-Theoretic and Mereological Approach, Adelaide, BA (Hons).
Hamish Tynan, On Truth and Consequence, Adelaide, BA (Hons).
Jeffrey Nicholls, The Universe Conceived as Divine Mind, Adelaide, BA (Hons).
James Vlachoulis, An Investigation into the Consequences that Arguments in the Philosophy of Memory have for Debates within the Metaphysics of Time, Adelaide, BA (Hons).
Trevor Smith, Light Signals and Preferred Foliations: Presentism and the Relativistic Objections, Adelaide, BA (Hons).
Julia Mak, Fine’s Standard Realism as an A-Theory, Adelaide, BA (Hons).
Astrid LaneNegative Causal Claims, Adelaide, BA (Hons).
Charlotte Lawrence, Structural Realism – a middle way?, Oxford, MPhysPhil.
Matthew Hodgetts, Mereological Nihlism, Oxford, BA.


University of Adelaide
University of Oxford
Exeter College
Princeton University
Tutorials in Philosophy of Physics: Quantum Mechanics (S 2001) and Introduction to Metaphysics and Epistemology (F 2000).
Melbourne University
Tutorials for Introduction to Formal Logic and Logic and Rationality (Semester 1, 1999).

Professional Service

Member of Editorial Board, Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 2010–
Member of Editorial Panel, Thought, 2012–
Member of Editorial Committee, Oxford Philosophical Monographs, 2011–3
Editor, ‘Chance and Determinism’ category, PhilPapers, 2009–
Thesis Examining
University of Auckland (2014); University of Oxford (2014).
Two as external reviewer.
Conferences Organised
Part of organising committee AAP 2017 (Adelaide).
Organised Adelaide Philosophy Work in Progress Colloquium, University of Adelaide, February 2016.
Organised Philosophy of Probability Mini Conference, Faculty of Philosophy, Oxford, September 2009.
Public Philosophy
Philosothon judging: SA 2019 (head judge), 2017; Australian 2018.
Australasian Association for Philosophy (AAP)
Aristotelian Society
Australasian Association for the History, Philosophy, and Social Studies of Science
Philosophy of Science Association
Society for the Metaphysics of Science
Treasurer, 2014–20
Board/Council member, 2014–21
Finance and Risk Committee, 2015–21; Chair 2015–20
Executive, 2015–20

University Service

University of Adelaide
Program Coordinator, Bachelor of Philosophy, Politics and Economics, 2018–.
Head of Philosophy, 2018–20.
Member of Faculty of Arts GEDI committee, 2021–.
Member, Fay Gale Centre for Research on Gender, 2021–.
ECR Network convenor, Faculty of Arts, S2 2018.
Postgraduate Coordinator (Asian Studies, Art History, Education, and Philosophy), 2017.
Philosophy Honours Coordinator, 2015.
University of Oxford
Director of Graduate Admissions, 2010–12.
Member, Working Group on Strategic Planning, 2011–2.
Member, Graduate Studies Committee, 2009–12.
Member, Mathematics and Philosophy Joint Standing Committee, 2009.
Member, First Year Review Group (review and revision of first year provision in all joint schools involving philosophy), 2008–10.
Member, Undergraduate Joint Consultative Committee, 2005–7.
Joint President of the Philosophical Society (speaker series), 2005–7.
Joint Convener, Philosophy of Science Research Seminar, M 2005.
Search committees, Pembroke College and Somerville College, 2005–06.
Graduate examining: BPhil options: Metaphysics and Epistemology (2005–07; 2008–11), BPhil theses (2005, 1 thesis; 2007, 2 theses; 2008, 2 theses; 2009, 2 theses; 2010, 1 thesis; 2011, 2 theses), MSt Theology theses (2011, 1 thesis).
Undergraduate examining: Examiner, PPE, 2011–14; Physics and Philosophy Mods 2009–10 (Chair, 2009); Mathematics and Philosophy Mods 2009–10; Psychology, Philosophy and Physiology, and Philosophy and Theology Prelims, 2005–07.
Exeter College, Oxford
Member of Rector and Tutors Committee, 2010–13.
Tutor for Graduates, 2010–11.
Member of IT committee and staff committee, 2008–10.
Philosophy (and joint schools) admissions interviewing, 2004–12 (Group organising secretary in PPE, 2009–10).
Member of governing body, 2004–13.